The Man Behind the House 

Ansley Wilcox

Theodore Roosevelt never lived in the Buffalo home where his inauguration took place on September 14, 1901. At the time, 641 Delaware Avenue was the home of Ansley and Mary Grace Wilcox.

Born in Summerville, Georgia, Ansley Wilcox moved to Buffalo in 1876. He would become a leading figure in Buffalo's Charity Organization Society and the American Red Cross. In 1878, he married Cornelia Rumsey, daughter of one of Buffalo's most prominent families. He was widowed less than three years later, and left with an infant daughter named Nina. On November 20, 1883, Ansley married his first wife's younger sister, Mary Grace Rumsey.

 

Ansley Wilcox and Theodore Roosevelt

No record has been found of the first meeting between Theodore Roosevelt and Ansley Wilcox, but it is clear that they knew each other long before 1901. They probably first crossed paths in the 1880's, when Theodore Roosevelt was in the New York State Assembly (1882-84). During this time, they shared some common concerns.

One of these was the preservation of Niagara Falls. The falls had long been recognized for its natural beauty, but by the mid-19th century the surrounding land had become choked with factories and mills harnessing the tremendous waterpower of the swift-moving Niagara River, as well as tourist-oriented vendors hawking their wares. A movement began to restore and preserve the natural condition of the falls and provide the public unimpeded free access to this spectacle. In 1883 the New York State Legislature —with the backing of Governor Grover Cleveland— authorized the acquisition of land surrounding the falls for the establishment of a state park. Ansley Wilcox served as one of the attorneys for the state's Niagara River Commission, helping make this vision a reality by representing New York State in acquiring the land. In later years, he would serve as one of the Niagara Reservation's commissioners. Theodore Roosevelt —already an active advocate of conservation— did his part as a member of the Niagara Falls Association; an organization dedicated to promoting public and legislative support for the Niagara Reservation. Later, as president, Roosevelt would play a far larger role in the service of conservation of our nation's resources.

Another common cause of the two men was civil service reform. Since its inception, American government had been ruled by the principle of patronage; the practice of office-holders granting government jobs to political supporters. This "spoils system" allowed political parties to build support by handing out plum positions to loyal backers. Therefore, the established order had a great investment in the practice of patronage as a means to promote and maintain their influence. Others had begun to see that the practice —which often resulted in promotions by favoritism rather than merit, and to the periodic post-election house-cleaning of experienced workers— led to government inefficiency, corruption, and incompetence.

Theodore Roosevelt and Ansley Wilcox were both active supporters of the cause of civil service reform. Roosevelt served as a member of the New York Civil Service Reform Association in the early 1880s. Wilcox helped to organize the National Civil Service Reform League, and was a founder of the Buffalo Civil Service Reform Association, which he would serve as president of for several years. As a member of the New York State Assembly, Roosevelt worked with New York Governor Grover Cleveland to push civil service reform legislation, despite their different party affiliations. While Assembly Minority Leader, Roosevelt pushed for the New York Civil Service Act of 1883, the first state civil service act in the nation. In 1889 Roosevelt was appointed as United States Civil Service Commissioner by President Benjamin Harrison, and subsequently reappointed by President Grover Cleveland.

Though he never ran for public office, Wilcox was very interested in politics. He was a friend of at least three Presidents (Cleveland, Roosevelt, and Taft). He supported Roosevelt in the 1904 presidential campaign, but gave his support to Republican incumbent Taft in 1912, rather than to Progressive Party candidate Roosevelt.

It would overstate the case to say that Theodore Roosevelt and Ansley Wilcox were close friends. TR was certainly not a regular guest at the Wilcox home. However, Roosevelt did maintain professional ties to Wilcox over the years, and it can be surmised that he respected Wilcox’s professional ability and personal integrity

 

Ansley Wilcox the lawyer

In 1890, attorney Wilcox defended the 1883 new York Civil Service Act (The same act Roosevelt worked to enact) in the case of Rogers v. Buffalo, and firmly established its constitutionality. In 1891, Wilcox argued the case of Briggs versus Spaulding before the United States Supreme Court.

A long-time advocate of separating federal and state elections from municipal elections, Wilcox played a key role in the fight to institute this procedure during the 1894 New York State Constitutional Convention. He is credited with developing the proposal to hold city and county elections in odd-numbered years, and state elections in even-numbered years; thus freeing municipal governments from some of the tumultuous politics associated with state elections. Wilcox claimed this to be his greatest single achievement.

While Roosevelt served as Governor of New York State (1899-1900), he appointed Wilcox to hear charges against District Attorney Asa Bird Gardiner of New York County. The investigation led Governor Roosevelt to remove Gardiner from office in December of 1900 for failure to uphold the law in protection of fair elections.

From 1885-1906, Ansley Wilcox was a professor of Medical Jurisprudence at the University of Buffalo. In 1913-14, he was one of the commissioners to examine public health laws of New York State. Wilcox also served on a commission that investigated allegations of cruelty to prisoners at the Elmira Reformatory.

 

Ansley Wilcox's first-hand account of Theodore Roosevelt's inauguration
1919 reprint of Theodore Roosevelt, President

 


About a year after Theodore Roosevelt's impromptu inauguration in the library of his home, Ansley Wilcox recorded his memories of the event in an essay he called "Theodore Roosevelt, President." Wilcox sent Roosevelt a draft copy of the essay on 20 November 1902, asking him to verify the accuracy of the account. The President responded a short two days later with his approval and a few additional notes regarding his breakneck journey down from the Adirondacks and back to Buffalo.


Originally published to benefit the Buffalo School Teachers Retirement Fund, Wilcox's essay was reprinted after Theodore Roosevelt's death in 1919. This marked up copy was found among Ansley Wilcox's personal papers and was likely used by the author during a reading he gave at Buffalo's Athletic Club on 27 October 1925 (the 67th anniversary of TR's birth).  The notation "Kohlsat Book" on the back cover likely refers to the 1923 publication From McKinley to Harding: Personal Recollections of Our Presidents, by H. H. Kohlsaat.


Theodore Roosevelt, President

Written by Ansley Wilcox in October, 1902 and Revised by Theodore Roosevelt

"The people of Buffalo will always have a special interest in the presidency of Theodore Roosevelt, because it was in this city that the awful tragedy occurred which made him President, and it was here that he was sworn in, made his first proclamation, and from here be followed the body of his former chief to its last resting place.

But Col. Roosevelt was well known to Buffalonians, and he knew the city and its people well, before that memorable week in September, 1901, when he unwillingly became the central figure of the world's gaze. His last previous visit was on May 20th of the same year, when he came here as Vice-president to open formally the Pan-American Exposition, around which all our hopes were clustering. At that time, he met many of our people and made as many friends by his simple, hearty and well souled manner. It was then that he, as well as Senator Lodge, in their speeches, developing the Pan-American idea which was the underlying motive of the exposition, gave utterance to thoughts which have been seen proved pathetic, as outlining some phrases of the foreign policy of the new administration, and especially the new and more energetic hegemony of the United States on this continent - the revivified Monroe Doctrine.

Only a little more than a year before this, on Washington's birthday, in 1900, Col. Roosevelt, then Governor, had come to Buffalo and delivered an address on the higher duties of citizenship at the Saturn Club, and with his usual energy, he gave another address the same evening before the Daughters of the American Revolution, and still another before the Sixty-fifth Regiment, after a review.

So when on Friday, the sixth of September (1901), he heard of the shooting of President McKinley at the Pan-American Exposition, and instantly started for the side of his chief, he knew he was not going among strangers but to the house of friends. He hardly stopped to consult anyone of his movements, but simply came to where the trouble was fast as a special train could bring him.

It was almost by chance that I met him on Saturday noon, as he drove up to the Iroquois Hotel, and a brief conversation resulted in his coming to stay at my house and stopping there until the following Tuesday. The house was then partly dismantled, the family and most of the household were in the country, but he was offered a quiet place to sleep and eat, and accepted it.

Those were terribly anxious days, but on the whole not gloomy. From the first moment of his arrival, and the favorable answers which were made to his questions about the condition of the President - especially after his first hasty call on the family and physicians of the wounded man, at Mr. (John) Milburn's house, the Vice-president seemed possessed with an abiding faith that the wound would not be fatal. His sanguine temperament, his own rugged strength and consciousness of ability to combat disease, and his eager desire, yes, longed for recovery of another, with all his might, that did Theodore Roosevelt, when he stood in the shadow of President McKinley's threatened death. Apart from all other consideration, he did not want to have the presidency thrust upon him in that terrible way. He would not believe it possible.

So when, on Tuesday, the fourth day after the shooting, everything seemed to be going well, and even the Secretary of War, Mr. (Elihu) Root, and other members of the cabinet, and Dr. Burney, who had come here from New York, felt justified in leaving, it was thought best that the Vice-president also should go away in order to impress the public with that confidence in the outcome which everyone felt. He went to join his family at a remote spot in the Adirondacks, the Tahawus Club, where he expected to stop only for a day, and then take them back to his home at Oyster Bay. His itinerary and addresses for reaching him, if he should be needed here, were left with me but no one thought that he would be needed.

In the middle of the night between Thursday and Friday, I was aroused by a messenger asking me to send instantly for the Vice-president, as the President had suddenly become worse and was in great danger. Then began a vigorous effort to annihilate time and space. A telephone message to Albany, put me, within two hours, in direct communication with Mr. Loeb, the Vice-president's secretary. He informed me that the club where Col. Roosevelt probably was at that moment, was some hours beyond the end of the rail and telegraph lines, but that he was probably coming out that day; that he (Mr. Loeb) would try to reach him quickly by a telegram, to be forwarded by special messenger, and would also go after him on a special train as early in the morning as one could start.

It turned out that Col. Roosevelt and his family were staying a day longer in the Adirondacks than he had expected, owing in part, as I understand, to a storm which had washed out the roads and made them very bad. Being thus detained, on this Friday, the Vice-president had started for a tramp up Mt. Marcy with a guide, before the telegram from Mr. Loeb arrived. The message was sent after him and found him on his way down the mountain, just below the summit.

He hurried back; as soon as possible got a wagon and drove out over the rough roads to the nearest railway station, in the dark of Friday night. It is safe to say he lost no time on that drive.

Saturday, September 14th, about 1:30 pm, he arrived in Buffalo again and left the train at the Terrace Station. President McKinley had died early Saturday morning, and he was then the constitutional President of the United States. Naturally, there was great excitement in the city, and all precautions were taken for his safety. He was met at the station by a single private carriage (Mr. George L. Williams) and by Mr. Williams and myself and was driven rapidly up to my house again, followed by a small escort of cavalry, which had been stationed off at some distance in order not to attract a crowd.

No definite plans had been made for the swearing him in, and it had not even been settled where this should be done. The first suggestion had been to take him directly to Mr. Milburn's house, there to be sworn in, but this had been objected to as unsuitable, while the body of the President was lying in the house. So he was asked to go to my house to get lunch, and immediately at arriving and being equipped with borrowed clothes, more appropriate than his traveling suit, he insisted on starting for Mr. Milburn's house, to make a call of sympathy and respect on the family of the dead President. This was done, and by three o'clock he was at my house again.

Then without any preparation, and almost without announcement, the members of the cabinet came down to administer the oath of office.

They were the Secretary of War, Mr. (Elihu) Root; the Secretary of the Navy, Mr. (John) Long; the Attorney General, Mr. (Philander) Knox; the Secretary of the Interior, Mr. (Ethan) Hitchcock; the Postmaster General, Mr. (Charles Emory) Smith; and the Secretary of Agriculture, Mr. (James) Wilson. With them were Judge (John) Hazel, of the United States District Court, and Judge Haight, of the New York Court of Appeals, Senator Depew, and a few friends who happened to know of it.

President Roosevelt met with them informally in the Library as they came in. The room, not a large one, was far from full, and at the last moment, the newspaper men, who were eager for admission, were all let in, but were prohibited from taking any photographs. Therefore the newspaper accounts of what was said and done in the brief ceremony which followed are generally correct, but all professed pictures of the scene are shams, except as they may have been sketched from memory.

The Secretary of War, Mr. Root, was head of the cabinet, among the six who were present - the Secretaries of State and of the Treasury not being there. He was also an old and intimate friend of Col. Roosevelt, and his chief advisor at this trying time. Without any preliminaries, he addressed the new President, calling him "Mr. Vice-president," and on behalf of the cabinet requested him to take the oath of office.

President Roosevelt answered simply, but with great solemnity: "Mr. Secretary - I will take the oath. And in this hour of deep and terrible national bereavement, I wish to state that it shall be my aim to continue, absolutely without variance, the policy of President McKinley, for the peace and honor of our beloved country."

It is characteristic of the man that when, the next day, some newspapers published this statement without the word "honor" - referring only to "peace and prosperity" - he was concerned about it, and asked earnestly whether he possibly could have omitted a word to which he intended to give special emphasis.

The new President was standing in front of the bay window on the south side of the room. Others had fallen back a little when Mr. Root spoke. After his response, Judge Hazel advanced and administered the oath to support the constitution and laws. It was taken with uplifted hand. The written oath, which Judge Hazel produced, in typewritten form, on a sheet of ordinary legal cap, was then signed.

Then President Roosevelt made the announcement of his request to the cabinet to remain in office. The whole ceremony was over within half an hour after the cabinet had entered the house, and the small company dispersed, leaving only the six cabinet officers with the President, who at once held an informal session in the library.

I was asked to produce the "Messages and Papers of the President" - the volume containing the proclamation by President (Chester) Arthur of the death of President (James) Garfield, and did so. This was considered in the cabinet meeting, which only lasted a few minutes.

After this meeting the President took a walk with Mr. Root, and then returning to the house, drafted his proclamation of the death of President McKinley, and appointing Thursday, September 19th, a day of national mourning. This was issued to the press that evening.

So began President Roosevelt's term of office. The next day, Sunday, came the local funeral ceremonies over his predecessor, and early Monday morning he started with the funeral train for Washington.

It takes less in the way of ceremony to make a President in this country, than it does to make a King in England or any monarchy, but the significance of the event is no less great."

 

 

Photo credits 2